Salmond Jurisprudence Notes for LAW-GAT (Exam Summary)

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. What jurisprudence means
  2. Salmond's definition of law
  3. Kinds of law
  4. Administration of justice
  5. Sources of law
  6. Legal rights and duties
  7. Possession and ownership
  8. Persons
  9. Obligations and liability
  10. Sample questions from past papers
  11. Frequently Asked Questions

English Jurisprudence in LAW-GAT means Salmond on Jurisprudence. HEC tests Salmond's definitions almost word for word: "the law of the land", "administration of justice", "courts of justice", "corpus and animus". These Salmond jurisprudence notes cover the topics past papers have used, in the order they appear in the book, so you can revise the whole chapter in one sitting.

What jurisprudence means

In its widest sense, jurisprudence is the science of law. Salmond takes "law" here to mean civil law, the law of the land, and calls the study of it civil jurisprudence. It has three branches:

BranchConcerned with
Systematic (expository)The content of an actual legal system as it exists
HistoricalHow the legal system developed
CriticalThe law as it ought to be. Salmond calls this the science of legislation

HEC has blanked each of these words, so learn the three names and what each covers.

Salmond's definition of law

Salmond defines law as "the body of principles recognised and applied by the State in the administration of justice". Put more simply, law consists of the rules recognised and acted on by courts of justice.

His approach looks at law from the courts' side. Austin's looks at it from the legislature's side. For Austin, law is the command of the sovereign backed by a sanction, and the proper subject of jurisprudence is positive law. Both definitions are tested, so learn them as a pair.

Kinds of law

Salmond lists eight kinds of law:

  1. Imperative law: rules of action imposed by an authority
  2. Physical or scientific law: uniformities of nature
  3. Natural or moral law: principles of right and wrong
  4. Conventional law: rules agreed between persons, such as a club's rules
  5. Customary law: rules embodied in custom
  6. Practical or technical law: rules for achieving an end, such as the laws of health
  7. International law: rules between states
  8. Civil law: the law of the State, applied in courts

Administration of justice

Salmond treats the administration of justice as the main purpose of the State. Justice is maintained by the physical force of the State. It has two parts:

  • Civil justice: enforcing rights through remedies such as damages or specific performance.
  • Criminal justice: punishing wrongdoers.

The theories of punishment are deterrent, preventive, reformative and retributive. Salmond regards the deterrent theory as the most important.

He also notes that as justice comes to follow fixed rules, courts of justice become courts of law. Equity developed to correct the rigidity of law. HEC has asked who defined equity as the correction of law where it is defective owing to its universality. The answer is Aristotle. Matters before a court divide into questions of law and questions of fact.

Sources of law

Salmond divides sources into formal and material, and material sources into legal and historical. The legal sources are legislation, precedent, custom and agreement. This topic is covered in detail in our post on sources of law according to Salmond, and precedent in ratio decidendi vs obiter dicta.

A right is an interest recognised and protected by a rule of law. Salmond says every legal right has five elements:

  1. The person of inherence, who holds the right
  2. The person of incidence, who bears the correlative duty
  3. The content: the act or omission the duty requires
  4. The object: the thing over which the right exists
  5. The title: the facts by which the right is acquired

The correlative of a right in the strict sense is a duty. Hohfeld's scheme pairs right with duty, privilege with no-right, power with liability, and immunity with disability.

Kinds of rights you should know:

  • Perfect and imperfect
  • Positive and negative
  • In rem (a right against the world, literally "in respect of a thing") and in personam (against a specific person)
  • Proprietary and personal
  • Rights over one's own property (ownership) and over another's (encumbrances, such as leases, servitudes and securities)
  • Legal and equitable, vested and contingent, principal and accessory

The maxim ubi jus ibi remedium means "where there is a right there is a remedy".

Possession and ownership

Possession has two elements, the corpus possessionis (physical control) and the animus possidendi (intent to possess). HEC has asked this directly, and the answer is "corpus and animus". Ownership is the relation between a person and a right that is vested in them. It is the most complete right a person can have over a thing.

Persons

A person is any being capable of rights and duties. Persons are natural (human beings) or legal (for example corporations). A corporation sole is a single person holding an office, such as the Crown. A corporation aggregate has many members, such as a company. The branch of law dealing with marriage, parentage and guardianship is the law of persons (status).

Obligations and liability

The law of obligations covers contract, tort, quasi-contract and breach of trust. Contract is its most important branch. A tort is a civil wrong other than a breach of contract or trust. Liability may require mens rea (intention or negligence), or may be strict, where there is liability without fault.

Sample questions from past papers

  • "In its widest sense jurisprudence is the ___ of law." Answer: science.
  • "Critical jurisprudence is the science of ___." Answer: legislation.
  • "Elements of a legal right per Salmond are ___." Answer: five.
  • "Proponent of utilitarianism." Answer: Bentham, developed by J.S. Mill.

Practise many more on the English jurisprudence MCQs. Use Practice mode to learn the answers, then Revision mode (45 seconds each) to fix them in memory, and then the free 100-question mock test. Many maxims also come up here, so keep our legal maxims list handy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Salmond's definition of law?

Salmond defines law as the body of principles recognised and applied by the State in the administration of justice. In other words, law consists of the rules that courts of justice recognise and act on.

What are the three branches of civil jurisprudence?

Systematic (or expository), historical, and critical jurisprudence. Salmond calls critical jurisprudence the science of legislation, because it deals with what the law ought to be.

The person of inherence (owner of the right), the person of incidence (bearer of the duty), the content (the act or forbearance), the object (the thing the right relates to), and the title (the facts creating the right).

How many questions does English jurisprudence carry in LAW-GAT?

Most breakdowns of the HEC syllabus show about five MCQs from English jurisprudence. Check the current syllabus on hec.gov.pk, as the weightage can be revised.

Keep reading