Sources of Law According to Salmond: LAW-GAT Notes

· 5 min read

In this guide
  1. Salmond's classification of the sources of law
  2. 1. Legislation
  3. 2. Precedent
  4. 3. Custom
  5. 4. Agreement (conventional law)
  6. Comparing the four legal sources
  7. How this links to Islamic jurisprudence
  8. Practise sources of law MCQs
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

"Salmond's two kinds of sources of law are ___." HEC has asked this, and the answer, legal and historical, catches students who learned only "formal and material". The topic of the sources of law according to Salmond is short and logical. If you understand the classification once, you will get these marks every time. This post explains the classification, then each legal source, with the points LAW-GAT tests.

Salmond's classification of the sources of law

Salmond first separates two senses of "source":

  • Formal source: the source from which a rule gets its validity and force. For civil law, this is the will and power of the State, as shown in the courts.
  • Material source: the source from which a rule gets its content.

He then divides material sources into two kinds:

KindMeaningExamples
Legal sourcesSources that the law itself recognises as authoritative. Courts must follow themLegislation, precedent, custom, agreement
Historical sourcesSources that influence the law in fact, but have no legal authorityJuristic writings, foreign decisions, religion, morality

When an MCQ asks for "Salmond's two kinds of sources", the expected answer is legal and historical. The four legal sources are legislation, precedent, custom and agreement (conventional law).

1. Legislation

Legislation is law made by an authority competent to make it, usually through a formal declaration of legal rules. Salmond calls it the most powerful source because it can create, change or repeal any other kind of law.

Supreme and subordinate legislation

  • Supreme legislation comes from the sovereign power in the State, and no other legislative authority can repeal or control it. In Pakistan, Parliament acting within the Constitution is the nearest example.
  • Subordinate legislation comes from an authority that is not sovereign, and depends on a superior authority for its existence. HEC has asked: "law made under delegated authority is ___". The answer is subordinate legislation.

Salmond lists five kinds of subordinate legislation:

  1. Colonial
  2. Executive (rules made by the government under a statute)
  3. Judicial (rules of court, for example the procedural rules made by High Courts)
  4. Municipal (by-laws of local bodies)
  5. Autonomous (rules made by private bodies such as companies or universities)

A related maxim is delegatus non potest delegare: someone who has been delegated a power cannot delegate it again unless authorised to do so.

2. Precedent

A precedent is a judicial decision that contains a principle. The principle that forms its authoritative part is the ratio decidendi. Statements made beyond what the case needed are obiter dicta.

Precedents are either:

  • Authoritative: judges must follow them, for example decisions of higher courts.
  • Persuasive: judges may consider them but need not follow them, for example foreign judgments or obiter dicta.

Pakistan's Constitution makes precedent formally binding. Supreme Court decisions on a question of law bind all courts (Art. 189), and High Court decisions bind their subordinate courts (Art. 201). We cover this in detail in ratio decidendi vs obiter dicta.

3. Custom

Custom is the oldest source of law. Salmond explains its authority as the embodiment of principles accepted by the community as just and in the public interest. A custom must meet certain requirements before courts will apply it as law:

  1. Antiquity: in English law it must be immemorial, which by convention means since 1189 (the reign of Richard I).
  2. Continuity: it must have been observed without interruption.
  3. Peaceable enjoyment: it must have been exercised openly, not by force.
  4. Reasonableness: an unreasonable custom is not enforced.
  5. Certainty: it must be definite.
  6. Conformity with statute law: a custom cannot override an Act.
  7. Opinio necessitatis: it must be followed as of right, in the belief that it is obligatory.

Customs are general (across the country) or local (in a particular place). Salmond also discusses conventional custom, or usage, which binds because it is impliedly incorporated into agreements.

4. Agreement (conventional law)

Salmond treats agreement as a source of law because parties can create rules binding on themselves. A contract is law between the parties, and the rules of a club or company bind its members. Courts enforce agreements because the law recognises them.

There is a parallel in international law. Treaties are the main source between states, under the principle of pacta sunt servanda. See international law basics for LAW-GAT.

SourceMade byMain strengthMain weakness
LegislationLegislatureCan be made in advance and repeal other lawCan be rigid; general words may not fit cases
PrecedentCourtsGrows from real disputesDevelops slowly and only when cases arise
CustomCommunityReflects accepted practiceMay be uncertain; must satisfy tests
AgreementPartiesFlexibleBinds only the parties

Students often find it useful to compare Salmond's legal sources with the sources of Islamic law. Urf (custom) appears in both, and ijma (consensus) is sometimes compared to precedent. Our post on sources of Islamic law makes this comparison.

Practise sources of law MCQs

Revise the classification table until you can draw it from memory, then drill the English jurisprudence MCQs in Practice mode. Move to Revision mode, which gives you 45 seconds per question and shows the answer after each choice. For the rest of the chapter, read our Salmond jurisprudence notes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Legislation, precedent, custom and agreement (conventional law). They are called legal sources because the law itself recognises them as authoritative, and courts are bound to apply them.

Legal sources have legal authority, so courts must apply them. Historical sources, such as the writings of jurists, only influence the development of law in fact and have no binding authority.

What is subordinate legislation?

Subordinate legislation is law made by an authority below the sovereign legislature, using power delegated to it. Examples are executive rules, rules of court, municipal by-laws and autonomous rules of private bodies.

What are the essentials of a valid custom?

Antiquity, continuity, peaceable enjoyment, reasonableness, certainty, conformity with statute law, and observance as of right (opinio necessitatis).

Keep reading