Res Judicata and Res Sub Judice under CPC: LAW-GAT Notes

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. Res sub judice under section 10 CPC
  2. Res judicata under section 11 CPC
  3. The Explanations to section 11 in LAW-GAT
  4. Difference between res judicata and res sub judice
  5. Related provisions to connect
  6. Sample LAW-GAT questions
  7. Revision tip
  8. Frequently Asked Questions

Res judicata and res sub judice are two of the most frequently tested doctrines in the CPC portion of LAW-GAT. Both aim at the same goal, preventing a person from being dragged through the same litigation twice, but they work at different stages. Section 10 deals with a matter that is still pending; section 11 deals with a matter that has already been decided. If you understand that one line, half the MCQs on this topic become easy.

Res sub judice under section 10 CPC

Res sub judice means "a matter under judgment". Section 10 provides, in substance, that no court shall proceed with the trial of a suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties (or parties under whom they claim), litigating under the same title, where that earlier suit is pending in the same or another court in Pakistan competent to grant the relief claimed, or before the Supreme Court.

Conditions for section 10

  1. Two suits, one instituted earlier than the other.
  2. The matter in issue in the later suit is directly and substantially in issue in the earlier suit.
  3. The parties are the same, or parties under whom they or any of them claim.
  4. They litigate under the same title.
  5. The earlier suit is pending in a court competent to grant the relief claimed.

Key points

  • Section 10 bars the trial, not the institution, of the later suit. The second suit can be filed; the court simply stays it.
  • It is the later suit that is stayed, never the earlier one.
  • Under the Explanation, the pendency of a suit in a foreign court does not stop the courts in Pakistan from trying a suit founded on the same cause of action.

Res judicata under section 11 CPC

Res judicata means "a matter already adjudged". Section 11 says no court shall try a suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties (or parties under whom they claim), litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try the subsequent suit, and has been heard and finally decided by that court.

Conditions for section 11

  1. The matter must be directly and substantially in issue in both suits.
  2. The former suit was between the same parties or their privies.
  3. The parties litigated under the same title.
  4. The former court was competent to try the subsequent suit.
  5. The matter was heard and finally decided.

The rule rests on two maxims: nemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causa (no one should be vexed twice for the same cause) and interest reipublicae ut sit finis litium (it is in the public interest that litigation should come to an end). These maxims also appear in the legal maxims guide.

The Explanations to section 11 in LAW-GAT

HEC likes the Explanations more than the main section. Focus on these:

ExplanationRule
I"Former suit" means a suit decided before the suit in question, whether or not it was instituted before it
IIIThe matter must have been alleged by one party and denied or admitted, expressly or impliedly, by the other
IVAny matter which might and ought to have been made a ground of defence or attack in the former suit is deemed to have been directly and substantially in issue (constructive res judicata)
VAny relief claimed in the plaint which is not expressly granted is deemed to have been refused
VIWhere persons litigate bona fide in respect of a public or private right claimed in common, all persons interested are deemed to claim under them

Explanation IV is called constructive res judicata. It stops a party from holding back a ground in the first suit and using it to start a second one. Explanations V and VI are both past-paper questions: "relief claimed but not expressly granted is deemed to be refused" and "persons litigating bona fide".

Difference between res judicata and res sub judice

PointRes sub judice (s. 10)Res judicata (s. 11)
Stage of the earlier matterPendingFinally decided
EffectTrial of later suit is stayedLater suit or issue is barred
PurposeAvoid conflicting decisions by parallel courtsGive finality to decisions
Foreign courtPendency abroad does not bar a suit in PakistanForeign judgments are dealt with separately in sections 13 and 14
  • Order II Rule 2: a suit must include the whole of the claim; a portion intentionally omitted cannot be sued for later. It works alongside res judicata.
  • Section 12: where a plaintiff is barred by rules from instituting a further suit on a particular cause of action, he cannot file it in any court.
  • Section 12(2): a party alleging that a decree was obtained by fraud, misrepresentation or want of jurisdiction applies to the court that passed it.

Sample LAW-GAT questions

  1. Section 10 embodies the doctrine of: (a) res judicata (b) res sub judice (c) lis pendens (d) estoppel.
  2. Section 11 embodies: (a) res judicata (b) res sub judice (c) inherent powers (d) set-off.
  3. Res judicata means a matter: (a) pending (b) stayed (c) already adjudged (d) under appeal.
  4. Under Explanation V, relief claimed but not expressly granted is deemed: (a) granted (b) refused (c) neither (d) settled.

You will find many more in the CPC 1908 MCQ chapter. Try them in Revision mode, where you get 45 seconds per question and the answer is revealed once you pick, so mistakes stick in memory.

Revision tip

Draw a timeline: Suit 1 filed, Suit 2 filed, Suit 1 decided. While Suit 1 is pending, section 10 applies to Suit 2. Once Suit 1 is decided, section 11 applies. Then read the Explanations to section 11 once more. That is usually enough for every LAW-GAT question on this topic. For a wider view of the Code, see CPC 1908 important sections.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does section 10 stop a plaintiff from filing a second suit?

No. Section 10 only bars the court from proceeding with the trial of the later suit. The suit can be instituted, but its trial is stayed while the earlier suit is pending.

What is constructive res judicata?

It is the rule in Explanation IV to section 11. Any ground that might and ought to have been raised in the former suit is treated as if it had been raised and decided, so it cannot be raised in a fresh suit.

Does res judicata apply to writ petitions and other proceedings?

The general principle of res judicata has been applied by the superior courts beyond ordinary suits, on grounds of public policy. For LAW-GAT, however, questions stay with the text of section 11 and its Explanations.

Which is more important for LAW-GAT, section 10 or section 11?

Section 11 carries more questions because of its Explanations, but HEC regularly asks which section embodies which doctrine, so learn both.

Keep reading