Admission and Confession under Qanun-e-Shahadat: LAW-GAT Guide

· 6 min read

In this guide
  1. What is an admission?
  2. What is a confession?
  3. Rules excluding confessions (Articles 37 to 43)
  4. Retracted confessions
  5. Admission versus confession
  6. Sample LAW-GAT questions
  7. Frequently Asked Questions

Admissions and confessions are among the most tested topics in the Qanun-e-Shahadat portion of LAW-GAT. The articles are short, the rules are strict, and HEC tests them by blanking out a single word: "against", "irrelevant", "shall not be proved". This guide explains admission and confession under the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, the difference between them, and the rules on police confessions and retraction.

What is an admission?

Article 30 defines an admission as a statement, oral or documentary, which suggests any inference as to a fact in issue or relevant fact, and which is made by any of the persons and in the circumstances mentioned in the Order.

Who can make an admission (Articles 31 to 33)

  • A party to the proceeding, or his agent authorised for the purpose.
  • A person suing or sued in a representative character, while holding that character.
  • A person with a proprietary or pecuniary interest in the subject-matter, in that character.
  • A person from whom a party derives his interest in the subject-matter.
  • A person whose position must be proved against a party (Art. 32).
  • A person expressly referred to by a party for information (Art. 33).

Key rules on admissions

ArticleRule
34Admissions are relevant and may be proved against the person who makes them, not ordinarily by or on his behalf
35Oral admissions as to the contents of documents are not relevant, unless secondary evidence of the document is admissible
36In civil cases, an admission made on an express condition that evidence of it is not to be given (a "without prejudice" admission) is not relevant
45Admissions are not conclusive proof of the matters admitted, but they may operate as estoppels

What is a confession?

The Order does not define "confession". The accepted meaning is an admission made by a person accused of an offence, stating or suggesting the inference that he committed the crime. In short, every confession is an admission, but not every admission is a confession. A confession should admit the offence, or at any rate substantially all the facts which constitute it.

Judicial and extra-judicial confessions

  • A judicial confession is made before a Magistrate or in court. Under section 164 CrPC a Magistrate records it after warning the accused that he is not bound to confess and satisfying himself that it is voluntary; section 364 governs the manner of recording.
  • An extra-judicial confession is made outside court, for example to a private person. Courts treat it as weak evidence that needs strong corroboration.

Rules excluding confessions (Articles 37 to 43)

Article 37: inducement, threat or promise

A confession is irrelevant in a criminal proceeding if it appears to have been caused by any inducement, threat or promise, having reference to the charge, proceeding from a person in authority, and sufficient to give the accused reasonable grounds for supposing he would gain an advantage or avoid an evil.

Article 38: confession to a police officer

No confession made to a police officer shall be proved as against a person accused of any offence. This is absolute, whatever the circumstances.

Article 39: confession in police custody

A confession made while the accused is in the custody of a police officer cannot be proved against him unless it is made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate.

Article 40: discovery of facts

This is the exception to Articles 38 and 39. When a fact is discovered in consequence of information received from an accused in police custody, so much of the information as relates distinctly to the fact discovered may be proved, whether it amounts to a confession or not. The classic example is the accused leading police to the place where the weapon was hidden.

Article 41: removal of the impression

If the impression caused by an inducement, threat or promise has been fully removed in the opinion of the court, a confession made afterwards is relevant.

Article 42: other circumstances

A confession otherwise relevant does not become irrelevant merely because it was made under a promise of secrecy, as a result of deception, while the accused was drunk, in answer to questions he need not have answered, or without a warning that he was not bound to make it.

Article 43: confession of a co-accused

When more persons than one are tried jointly for the same offence and a confession by one of them affecting himself and others is proved, the court may take it into consideration against the others. Courts treat it as weak, circumstantial evidence that cannot by itself sustain a conviction.

Retracted confessions

An accused often retracts a judicial confession at trial, claiming coercion. A retracted confession can still be used, but as a rule of prudence courts look for corroboration in material particulars before convicting on it, and they examine closely whether it was voluntary and true. In qatl-i-amd liable to qisas, section 304 PPC requires a confession made before a competent court, which links this topic to qatl and hurt under PPC.

Admission versus confession

PointAdmissionConfession
ProceedingsCivil and criminalCriminal only
Made byParty, agent, or persons listed in Arts. 31 to 33The accused
ContentAny inference about a fact in issue or relevant factAdmits the offence or substantially all its facts
Use against othersGenerally notCo-accused confession under Art. 43, with caution
PoliceNo special barBarred by Arts. 38 and 39, subject to Art. 40

Sample LAW-GAT questions

  1. Art. 34: admissions are relevant (a) against (b) for (c) neutral to (d) only with consent of the maker.
  2. Art. 38: a confession to a police officer (a) is a judicial confession (b) is best evidence (c) is direct evidence (d) shall not be proved.
  3. Art. 42: a confession is not irrelevant merely because made (a) in a police station (b) without free consent (c) under duress (d) while drunk.
  4. Art. 43: a co-accused's confession is used against the other as (a) circumstantial evidence (b) secondary (c) corroborative (d) primary.

Practise the complete set in the Qanun-e-Shahadat MCQs using Revision mode, which reveals the answer right after you pick within 45 seconds. For the full article list, see Qanun-e-Shahadat important articles, and for how confessions are recorded, read CrPC 1898 important sections.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a confession to police admissible in Pakistan?

No. Article 38 says it shall not be proved against the accused. The only route in is Article 40, where information leads to the discovery of a fact.

Is an admission conclusive proof?

No. Under Article 45 admissions are not conclusive proof of the matters admitted, but they may operate as estoppels.

Can a conviction rest on a retracted confession?

It can in law, but courts as a rule of prudence require corroboration in material particulars and must be satisfied that the confession was voluntary and true.

Can a co-accused's confession alone convict another accused?

No. Under Article 43 it may only be taken into consideration against the other accused, and courts treat it as weak evidence that needs independent support.

Keep reading